Starred review from November 20, 2017
As a child in North Carolina at the end of the 19th century, Elizabeth Cotten taught herself to play her brother’s guitar. It didn’t matter that she was left-handed: she just played the guitar upside down. “It was kind of like brushing your teeth with your foot,” writes Veirs, a singer-songwriter making her children’s book debut. Cotten didn’t pursue a career in music (“Time swept Libba up, and she stopped playing guitar”), and when readers next see her, she is a grandmother working in a department store. After being hired as a housekeeper by Ruth Crawford Seeger, Cotten impressed the famous family of folk musicians with her playing, leading to a lovely second act as a musician. Newcomer Fazlalizadeh’s graphite drawings bring a moody atmosphere to Cotten’s story, an elegant and moving portrait of a musician’s late-in-life success and singular approach to her craft. Ages 5–8.
November 15, 2017
Grades K-3 Libba Cotten, who grew up at the turn of the twentieth century, taught herself to play her big brother's guitar. Left-handed, she played upside down. When her brother moved away, she worked and saved to buy her own guitar, which she played while making up songs. Decades later, after Ruth Crawford Seeger hired Libba Cotten as a housekeeper, her talent was discovered within that very musical home. As Veirs writes in a lengthy note, Cotten performed Freight Train, which she had written as a child, and other songs beginning in the 1950s and toured extensively for many years. Characterizing Cotten as a quiet, gentle soul, the straightforward text and informative author's note will mainly interest children and adults who love her music. The illustrations vary from a couple of scenes with awkwardly positioned figures to a handsome, expressive portrait of Cotten's face. Tinted with muted tans, blues, roses, greens, and grays, the softly shaded black drawings capture the tone of the story. A strong picture-book biography profiling a notable African American musician and songwriter.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2017, American Library Association.)
July 1, 2018
As a child, African American folk musician Elizabeth Cotten (18931987) taught her left-handed self to play guitar; then "time swept Libba up," and she stopped playing. As a grandmother, she's serendipitously hired as a housekeeper by the Seeger family, who rediscovered her talent and helped Cotten bring her music to the world. Fazlalizadeh's
art, rendered in graphite with feathery digital coloring, complements Veirs's unpretentious prose exquisitely. Websites.
(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)
May 1, 2018
In this picture-book biography of ?folk musician Elizabeth Cotten (1893-1987), a straightforward narrative describes her modest upbringing in rural North Carolina, where Libba taught herself to play her brother's right-handed guitar despite having no musical training and being herself left-handed. No matter: She turned the guitar upside down and played it backwards?Nobody else played that way, but it was the way that felt right to Libba. The backwards fingerpicking would become her trademark, but not until much, much later, as in her teens time swept Libba up, and she stopped playing guitar. From there the book jumps to Cotten's late adulthood when, as a grandmother, she's serendipitously hired as a housekeeper by the Seegers (yes, those Seegers), who would rediscover her talent and help Cotten bring her music to the world. Fazlalizadeh's ?art, rendered in graphite with feathery digital coloring, complements Veirs's unpretentious prose exquisitely, and the interplay between the two is seamless. Despite having written what would become her most famous song, Freight Train, at age eleven, Cotten's talent was sidetracked by her circumstances?she was an African American in the segregated South, a woman, and poor?until she was in her late fifties. That is, indeed, a story worth telling (as Veirs, herself a folk musician, puts it in her appended author's note), and this biography should inspire young readers starting to pursue their own creative ?talents. Also appended with a list of works cited (websites, videos, interviews, recordings, liner notes). ?katrina Hedeen
(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)
Starred review from November 1, 2017
A biography of folk-music icon Elizabeth Cotten.Cotten grew up hearing music in everything--everyday things. She would sneak her brother's guitar and play the sounds she heard, unconventionally playing the guitar upside down and backward--a way that made sense to her left-handedness. Though she eventually earned enough for her own guitar, as the years passed, Cotten didn't have time for music. One cleverly rendered illustration depicts various stages in Cotten's life in the cars of a passing freight train, explaining how her musical passion was (temporarily) derailed. When Cotten, now a grandmother working in a department store, encounters Ruth Crawford Seeger, Cotten becomes the musical family's housekeeper. One day, when Cotten picks up a guitar again--still playing upside down and backward--it's clear her talent and passion have not abandoned her...they've only lain dormant all those years. The Seegers use their privilege to help, and Cotten's talent is appreciated worldwide. Both endpapers and the book cover put guitar imagery to good use, and lovely graphite illustrations lend the story an old-time-y, country feel--a perfect pairing with Cotton's folk music. An inspiring tale of an artist who came into her own later in life than traditional narratives lead readers to believe is normal. (author's note, works cited) (Picture book/biography. 5-9)
COPYRIGHT(2017) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from December 1, 2017
K-Gr 3-As a child, Elizabeth Cotten, or Libba, heard a song everywhere she went, reverberating through the clear North Carolina air around her home. Sneaking into her brother's room one day, she began to play his guitar-upside down and backwards, since she was left-handed and the guitar was for right-handers. What came afterward is the beginning of a chapter in music history: "Freight Train," a song that lives in the annals of U.S. folk music. Veirs details Cotten's early determination to play guitar and the long deferment of that dream by daily life ("But even trains get derailed. Time swept Libba up"). Cotten would eventually be hired as a housekeeper for the Seeger family, her passion for song would be rekindled, and her childhood creation "Freight Train" would become a sensation. ("The Seegers believed in Libba...But it was Libba's perseverance, her love of music, and her belief in herself that gave the world her voice.") Veirs breaks up the narrative with poetic passages and with actual lyrics from Cotten's songs. Fazlalizadeh's earth-toned palette and softly blurred illustrations are imbued with warmth and contribute to the dreamy atmosphere. An extensive author's note provides a more detailed account of Cotten's life, the social and institutional barriers African Americans faced in the South, and the role the Seegers played in Cotten's fame. VERDICT The message of never giving up on a dream, no matter the circumstances, will resonate deeply with readers-purchase for all picture book biography collections.-Amanda C. Buschmann, Carroll Elementary School, Houston
Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.